Posts

Who Decides What Counts as an AI Revolution?

Image
Photo: Esra Erdem via Pexels A technology can change the way we work without changing everything people say it will change. I keep returning to that distinction whenever a new communication tool is described as a revolution. The 1938 War of the Worlds broadcast offers an older example. Some listeners were frightened by fictional news bulletins, while newspaper coverage made the incident into a much bigger public story about radio's influence. The episode mattered for what occurred and for what it supposedly demonstrated about audiences. A claim about transformation needs evidence of what changed, not only confidence that change is coming. When an event becomes a lesson The history becomes more interesting when we look at the institutions producing research about it. Pooley and Socolow (2013) examined archival evidence about the influential research that followed the broadcast. Their account shows how disputes over scholarly credit and interp...

What Happens Around a Message Matters Too

Image
Photo: cottonbro studio via Pexels I t seems reasonable that hearing a different opinion might help us reconsider our own. That would make a neat explanation. Yet a research paper about political disagreement shows why even a sensible expectation needs more than one explanation. In a 2018 field experiment, Bail and colleagues asked frequent American X/Twitter users to follow accounts sharing political messages from the other side. Participants were offered financial incentives, and researchers compared subsequent attitudes with those of a control group. Even a sensible expectation needs more than one explanation. The result is not the whole story Republican participants assigned to follow the opposing-view bot expressed more conservative views afterwards. The estimated change among Democrats was smaller and not statistically significant. The researchers did not find the straightforward movement towards agreement that a simple exposure argument migh...

What Lies Beyond the Frame?

Image
Photo: Michael Burrows via Pexels · Pexels License P hotography has taught me to pay attention to what happens at the edges of an image. When I compose a photograph, I decide where the frame begins and ends. That decision influences what becomes visible, what receives attention and what remains outside the picture. I am increasingly interested in what happens when somebody else sees the finished image. A photograph may provide accurate information about a moment while revealing little about what occurred before or afterwards. Yet viewers can construct a surprisingly complete explanation from what appears inside the frame. A photograph can be accurate about what it shows and incomplete about what it means. Prior choices Choosing a composition is part of ordinary photographic practice. Moving closer changes the emphasis; moving back provides more surroundings. An angle can alter how subjects and backgrounds appear related. These decisions d...

The Difference Between Sharing and Believing

Image
Photo: Beyzanur K. via Pexels · Pexels License I magine receiving an article accompanied by a short message: “Have you seen this?” There is no explanation of why it was sent. Perhaps the sender agrees with the article, doubts it, finds it amusing or simply wants to begin a conversation. It is tempting to read intention into that small act of sharing. Yet the message tells us very little about the sender's actual judgement. The more I examine mediated communication, the more interested I become in what we assume about people from the traces they leave behind. Passing information along is an observable action. Believing it is a different claim. What a share can mean A forwarded article can perform several functions. It may provide information, invite disagreement, signal concern, express humour or maintain a relationship. The same words can acquire different meanings depending on who sends them, to whom and in what circumstances. When r...

What Did I Actually See?

Image
Photo: Gustavo Fring via Pexels · Pexels License C onsider a television sequence in which one person speaks, the camera cuts to somebody else's expression and the scene ends in silence. It is easy to assemble a story from those images. The first person has upset the second; the silence means disagreement; perhaps the relationship has changed. I can see how quickly a few moments become an apparently complete account. Of course, that interpretation might be reasonable. What interests me is how difficult it can be to notice where the recorded material ends and my explanation begins. My growing interest in audiovisual learning has made that distinction particularly useful. The scene has an ending. My explanation of it may still be unfinished. What the sequence gives me Moving images are unusually effective at making events feel continuous. We see faces, hear voices and follow a sequence that appears to lead naturally from one action to the n...

What “Epistemic Communication” Means to Me

Image
Photo: Anna Keibalo via Pexels · Pexels License A headline can do a remarkable amount of work in very few words. It can tell us what happened, identify someone responsible, signal urgency and suggest how we ought to feel about the story. It can also make an interpretation sound like an established fact. One useful moment for me occurs when I notice that a headline has led me towards a conclusion before I have read the article. That is not evidence of deliberate manipulation. Headlines have limited space, and editors have real decisions to make. But it is a reason to notice where the words end and my own inference begins. When I use the phrase “epistemic communication”, I mean something quite practical: paying attention to how claims acquire the appearance of knowledge as they move between people. The headline tells me what to look at. I still need to decide what the evidence allows me to conclude. A report is not t...

From Headlines to Human Attention

Image
Photo: Max Bonda via Pexels · Pexels License I studied journalism long before I became interested in psychology, adult education and the questions about communication that occupy so much of my attention today. At the time, I probably thought of journalism as preparation for a particular profession. Looking back, I am beginning to appreciate something else: it also taught me a way of approaching information. What deserves attention? What needs explaining? What can be left out without losing something important? And how do we turn a great deal of material into something another person can actually follow? Those questions have followed me much further than I might once have expected. Journalism taught me that communicating more information is not necessarily the same as communicating better. The discipline of choosing One of journalism's most useful lessons is that information has to be organised. A report ca...